In the Police Court yesterday..
Michael Toohy,
Henry Reid
James Campbell -
where all brought up. Mr Dunne appeared on behalf of
Reid.
-Sub Inspector FURNELL
:..
"I was present on Sunday morning at Eureka,
in command
of the mounted police. About the end of the firing saw Reid inside the
stockade.Told hime to come out as he was a prisoner.He refused.Fired at him.
He had no arms then. He was brought out."
-Michael LAWLOR,
Sergeant Major in the mounted police, was at the attack of
of the stockade.
"Charged the flank of the stockade.
Reid fired at them
with a long piece He was by the tent called the guard tent. the balls were coming
very thick at that time.Did not see him fire.Wheeled, and on turning back saw the
prisoner nearly on the same spot.Will not swear whether he was armed then.Fired
at him.Did no see him again until he was a prisoner."
cross examined "had been stationed at Ballaarat two months. Never saw Reid before
Could not be mistaken to his identity."
-John WHITE..trooper,
" on charging the stockade with
the last witness,
saw Reid in the stockade.He had a different dress on.He had a gun in his
hand up to the present" Will not swear as to whether he fired.A good many
shots where being ????? prisoner "
By the bench - "Is certain to his identity
Mr Eugene BELLAIRS:
" On Thursday week,Nov 30th, was riding with a friend
near what has since been found to be the Eureka Stockade.We asked the prisoner
James Campbell which was the road to Melbourne. he said he would show us.
He then gave a signal and wished to entice us near the stockade.Suspecting something,
turned by some tents, and when at some distance,some bullets passed close to us.Came home
by the Black Hill.On the road was stopped by a body of armed men,who asked
us if we where troopers.On looking at them again they said, "Thank God, you
are not".
Mr James RICHARDSON:
"Gaunt
corroborated the evidence of the last witness,he was with me".
by the prisoner:
"you spoke to me.You were not close enough to speak".
John SULLIVAN
: private of the 12th,
"received orders to fix bayonets to charge.
Saw Campbell run,from one tent to another.Cannot say whether he was armed.
It was inside the stockade.Was close to Captain Wise, who had fallen.
Took up his ground beside him.Then returned home."
Joseph RAYNER,
-private of the 40th,identifies Campbell.
"Saw him inside the
stockade armed with a pistol or revolver.Saw him fire, and then run back
between two tents.Did not see him again until he was a prisoner.He fired in
the direction of the troops at the distance of about ten paces"
The bench complimented this witness on the manner in which he gave his
evidence.
William RICHARDSON
- Corporal,40th mounted division.
"After the firing ceased,
Twohey was turned out of the stockade.He ran away from the foot police and
I rode after him.On nearing him, he threw himself down and threw away
his gun.When I first saw him he had a double barrelled gun in his hand.
Saw him coming out of the stockade.I arrested him"
John KING - trooper,
"at about fifteen minutes after the firing had ceased,
was in the stockade.Saw Twohey with a musket or fowling piece in hand.
Did not see him fire.Called to one of the troopers to follow him.
He did so and captured him."
John DOHERTY -
constable -
"saw Twohey running away from the stockade.He had
a double barrelled gun in his hand.Do not recognize any of the others"
THIS WAS A CASE FOR THE CROWN
Witnesses for the defence.
Joseph Penross knew Reid.
"They slept in one tent; are mates.Their tent is about
350 yards from the catholic church.on Sunday morning saw the soldiers
pass the Catholic church.Do now know what time it was.Were close to the tent.
Were going to see what the soldiers were about.
Met some troopers.Troopers told them to go with them, and that if they went quietly
it would be all the better for them. Will swear prisoner never was out of his sight
from Saturday morning till Sunday , when he saw him in the camp."
John PENNIHMAN
:"On Sunday morning was called by the last witness to see the prisoners
taken back to the Camp.Prisoner asked Reid to go across the road by the church.
It was about 150 yards from our tents.Reid and Penrose live about twelve feet
off from us in the nest tent."
cross examined - : "Saw Reid and Penrose arrested"
James WEARNE :
"soon after four on Sunday morning heard the firing on Eureka.
Went out and stopped until he thought the firing had abated.Peter HICKS and
William WEAR where his mates.Had know REID for twelve months.They went about
half-way up the Bakery Hill.Saw a disturbance there.Some troopers rode up
and spoke to them.Was not near enough to hear what was said.Saw them pull up their
clothes,as if looking for arms. Saw them turn back with the troopers."
THE PRISONERS WHERE COMMITTED TO TAKE THEIR TRIAL FOR HIGH TREASON.
Thomas BOX was discharged. Mr Dunn appeared on his behalf
Thomas MAGHER
Thomas DEGAN
Richard ALLEN
Thos DIGNUM
where all charged.
Mr DUNNE appeared for MAYHER.-
William REVEL,
private 40th:
"I identify Dignem.He had an iron bar with a point, with
which he struck at me,but missed me, and ran it into my mare's flank.
I cut him over the head with my sword. The iron bar was eight or ten
feet long."
PRISONER REMANDED - The COURT ADJOURNED.
AT THE POLICE COURT ON SATURDAY......
Michael KENNEDY
William DEVELIN
John PARDY
Patrick KENNEDY
James SEXTON
Daniel MACARTNEY
James ASHBURN
John LEADOW
Herman STEINMAN
William WINKLEY
William SOMERVILLE
Jeremiah HOGAN
William AVONDALE
Samuel PENNY
Patrick HICKEY
Joseph WALKER
John KELLY
Cornelius PETERS
William STAFFORD
CARL ANDERSON - a Swede
Patrick MEADE
Michael GLEESON -
all were discharged. In some of these cases there was
either no evidence against the prisoners,or they where only proved guilty
of living in the neighborhood of the stockade, and giving no information
to its erection.
Edmund BOHEN
Michael MEAGHER
William GALLOWAY
James BARCLAY
Michael BUTLER
John LYNCH
Charles DOOLAN -
were defended by Mr Dunne and discharged.
DIGNEM and ALLEN,
remanded from the previous day, were recalled.
Inspector FOSTER
gave evidence that a license to "THOMAS WALKER"
was found on the person of DIGNUM.
Private REVEL
of the 40th was re -sworn :He stated that he had no
doubt about the identity of DIGNUM. He had cut him down.The wound
was on his head now.
DIGNUM WAS COMMITTED FOR TRIAL FOR THE CRIME OF HIGH TREASON>
ALLAN was discharged but with a caution
Patrick SHEEDY
Joseph ELLIS
Pergo - a Spaniard]
Romeo [an Italian]
were brought up. Mr Dynam was sworn to act as interpretor for Romeo,.
Pargo's case was conducted by the Bench in french.
Michael McADAM,
private of the 40th
saw SHEEDY taken "convanient" to a
tent about 200 yards from the stockade.
J.F.TULKIN -
a trooper,saw Romeo taken out of a tent about 150 yeards
from the Eureka stockade.He said as he went along towards the Camp.,
"Thank God, I have escaped with my life this morning.-I'll tell all
I know of this"
Trooper MAINGER -
"Saw Romeo taken, about 150 yards behind the stockade.
I saw many running towards a tent from the one next to which
Constable OCONNOR
brough Romeo with bloody hands."
Sergeant KING
gave the same evidence
REVEL -
of the mounted 40th,
was riding with others past the stockade.
Several shots where fired at them.Saw Ellis with a gun.Saw him fire,and
fired at him in return.On his return, saw Ellis in the act of getting
over the stockade:cut at him:thought he had killed him, and saw no more
of him till he was a prisoner."
ELLIS maintained that he was innocent:wished the trooper who had taken him
to be called.He did not know his name,but believed he was a sergeant,and
knew he was "fresh looking". Al the sergeants who where in the neighborhood
were called,and though they where all "fresh looking" the particular one
did not appear. he called
Edwad INGRAM ,his mate,who deposed that
ELLIS went to bed on Saturday night,
and got up the next morning to see the cause of the firing.They where plumers
and glaziers, and had been at work till 6 oclock on
Saturday evening.In the morning they went with
others on the hill to see what was the matter. When the troopers came in
sight,Ellis, who was frightened, went away and was captured.
He could bring tow others to corroborate these statements.Witness and his mate
had 'always been the other way'.
Patrick LYNOT,
private - 40th ,
saw ROMEO in the stockade.He was armed and much
agitated;looking to the right and left as if for a way of escape.
There was no doubt about his identity.Saw SHEADY come out of his tent
about 500 yards from the stockade .Is convinced that he only came out to
see what was doing.
William MURRELL
,corporal,40th,
saw PERGO, the Spaniard,at 100 - 150 yards
from the stockade.He was near a tent and had no arms.
Ellis called Mr MORGAN, auctioneer,who testified that the prisoner had been
working for him for three weeks:
had received his wages on Saturday about
6 o'clock.Prisoner was very industrious.Did not attend the meetings.Was always at
his work.and had not lost an hour in three weeks.
Sheady,Pergo and Romeo were discharged.Ellis was remanded till Monday, that
the other witnesses for the defence might appear.
Thomas Ferdinand TIGHE ,
who had been discharged the previous day, was
brought up on the charge of forcibly demanding goods as one of an armed
force,
The prisoner was defended by Mr LYNN.
W.H.COOPER
storeman to Mr SWEENY,deposed
that two men on horseback came
to him on Saturday night,the 2nd December, between 5 -6 o'clock,demanding
saddles:he said he could not give them, they said they would send for a
force to compel him:they sent away a messenger ,and about fifteen minutes
an armed party of about twenty came.In the interval he walked along from
his store and was stopped by a man on horseback,he believed the prisoner
TIGHE ,who presented a pistol at him.The armed men filled the tent, and
carried off twelve saddles and their acceuttrements.
THE PRISONER WAS REMANDED TILL MONDAY.
Thomas O'ROURKE
Charles KEDDAR
John PHELAN
William WRIGHT
- were then brought up and discharged with the exception
of PHELAN. Mr Dunne
spoke of O"Rourke's character,having known him in
Ireland.
Henry GOODENOUGH -
trooper -
saw PHELAN offering himself as a volounteer on
Wednesday,Nov 29th.He was being drilled at the armed-meeting on Thursday,
and again on Friday saw him aong the number marched from Bakery Hill to
Eureka.Saw him next a prisoner in the Camp on Sunday
Leonard COPACH,
Lietenant mounted police :
"fired at Phelan.He was armed when
in the stockade.The firing had almost ceased.
Lt HALL
jumped over the stockade
and captured him.
By the Bench - :"did not see him fire"
John CULKIS,trooper,
"saw Phelan in the stockade, armed.Fired at him,missed him.
Seeing him him attempting toget out of the stockade, knocked him
down the with flat of his sword. He was armed with a sword.Lt Hall captured
him and cuffed him.Mr Farnell recieved his sword."
Samuel FARNELL
corroborated the previous evidence as regard to his having
given up his sword.
FULLY COMMITTED FOR TRIAL FOR HIGH TREASON.
William MOLLOY,
Jacob LORENSON
Charles LEVISTON - {Livingston}
Patrick HOWARD
- were brought up .LIVINGSTON was discharged
Edward VIRET,
sergeant of police
"saw Malloy coming out of the stockade at
the conclusion of the firing. Told him to surrendour, and he did so.
In answer to the witness he said - on the way down "The row is just beginning
and would not end now". He was as sober then as now".
Thomas BROADLEY:
"Prisoner all the way down repeated that "the row was just begun and would
not end here".
MOLLOY WAS COMMITTED FOR TRIAL FOR HIGH TREASON.
James LOUGH
saw several men in the stockade near the guard tent.They were
armed with pikes and guns.
Saw HOWARD first.Was about to fire at him, but
fired at a much larger mob."
Sergeant KING
saw a number of men running away from the stockade, among
the holes towards some of the tents.
Lorenson was found in a tent,
which was burst open.He had a revolving gun in his hand.He surrendered,saying
"I am guilty" or something to that effect.
Inspector Foster
gave evidence that prisoner had on his person, when
brought into the Camp,balls,caps and a powder flask.
LORENSON WAS COMMITTED FOR TRIAL FOR HIGH TREASON.
Patrick HOWARD was discharged ,but told that he had had a narrow escape
James HEPBURN
Thomas MURPHY -
both discharged>
?gave evidence in favour of
BRYANT,
remanded from the previous day.He was in the employment of witness
for two years.Was an industrious peacible man,never attended the meetings,
and was at his work at seven O'clock the previous evening.He was warned
and discharged.
Michael Dynan
Andrew SWANSON - a Swede
were brought up.
Trooper GOODDENOUGH
saw Swanson at the meeting on Thursday,
with a bowie knife as long as his arm: he was admitted as a volunteer
and drilled. Constable Peters knew Swansen generally as a quiet and
peaceable man.Saw him at Bakery Hill;he was intoxicated.Said to
witness he had only come for the fun of it.
Private McADAM saw Dynan in the stockade at the Eureka, running with a child
in his arms,as if trying to escape.Another Constable corroborated this
evidence.Prisoner said he had been to see his sister,Mrs McAdam,from
Creswick's Creek.He had been detained in the stockade from the
Saturday night, and could not escape .
Swanson and DYNAN were BOTH DISCHARGED
Henry SEEKAMP,
who was out on bail, appeared.
Several numbers of the Ballaarat Times where put on.
Mr Dunne, for the traverser, admitted the proprietorship
of the newspaper.The Bench required Mr SEEKAMP to stand
on the floor of the court as a defendant.Mr Dunne said that
in the case of the Queen v OConnell and others, the
traversers occupied seats at the table besides the Queen's Counsel.
The bench stated that this was a courtesy to Mr OConnell and the
others.Mr Dunne was sure the Bench would be no less
"Courteous" in the present case.Mr Dunne would not require that
the extracts on which the charge was founded should be read.
The Bench preferred that the passages founded on should be
read by the clerk, and the traverser should stand up
before the Court as defendant.
The CLerk of the Court then read from the Ballaarat Times of the
18th and 25th Nov and 2nd Dec ,on which, with the whole leading article
of the 18th Nov, the charge was founded.
Inspector Carter
arrested Mr Seekamp in his own office on Monday,
on the charge of sedition.He believed that these leading articles
were the principal cause of the disturbance.Mr Dunne
submitted that this was not evidence.The Court
could receive from Mr Carter a statement of facts,not a judgement on them.
The bench thought Mr Carter entitled to state the grounds on which
he acted.Mr Carter resumed.
He had arrested Mr Seekamp,believing that the articles in his newspaper
were seditious.Mr Dunne declined to say anything.
Mr SEEKAMP WAS COMMITTED FOR TRIAL,
for publishing a seditous libel, but
was admitted to bail as before the committment.
| |